The Overlooked Way to Make Historical Fiction More Authentic

Many historical fiction writers already understand the more obvious reasons for low authenticity – factual inaccuracies, modern-sounding language, lack of attention to atmosphere, and so on.

As an editor, I’ve found there’s another, less commonly discussed reason a story doesn’t end up feeling as authentic as readers hope.

Writers in our genre are usually vigilant, even obsessive, about micro-level historical detail. This is understandable. What they often don’t think enough about, though, is shaping their stories with the setting in mind on the macro level. That macro level—plot and character arcs—is where reader-satisfying authenticity lives.

Let me show you what I mean.

How to Build Authenticity into Plot and Character

Before we go further, let’s get on the same page about what ‘authenticity’ means.

It’s not the same as accuracy, which is alignment with the historical record.

Authenticity is the reader’s subjective sense of immersion in the historical setting. We can think of it as the extent to which a story element feels believable for its setting—psychologically, culturally, socially.

Micro-level descriptive details can enhance readers’ sense of a setting’s psychology, culture, and social dynamics. But substantial immersion in those things usually requires larger-scale story elements.

What most effectively creates that subjective sense of immersion is the incorporation of setting-specific elements into plot and character arcs.

If a story’s plot and character arcs could play out the same way anywhere or in any era, the story is probably not making effective use of its setting.

As a result, readers are less likely to feel that the setting delivered on its promise. I see this constantly in reader reviews lamenting that a novel didn’t deliver on its setting—not because it was inaccurate, but because the setting simply didn’t matter much to the story.

Infusing plot and character arcs with setting-specific elements is one way to make the setting unequivocally matter.

This doesn’t mean every plot event and character arc needs to be setting-specific. It means being on the lookout for opportunities to include setting-specific elements as you outline, draft, and revise, rather than reaching for something more generic.

What Setting-Specific Elements to Incorporate

For best results, incorporate interesting setting-specific elements.

Think about what elements of your setting spark curiosity and suggest drama even before you explain them. Don’t think about what fascinates you now, as someone who’s spent countless hours teasing out the nuances of your setting. Instead, focus on what first grabbed you and made you want to learn more.

That’s the level many of your readers are operating on.

I believe this is why we so often see successful stories about gladiators in ancient Rome and mummies in their elaborate tombs in ancient Egypt. While not all stories in those settings need to include those exact tropes, their popularity is evidence that readers enjoy experiencing elements distinctive to the setting and exciting to the imagination. It’s often a major reason they picked up the book in the first place.

Examples of Authentic Plot and Character Arcs

An Authentic Plot Arc

For plot, consider how your setting can generate external conflicts for your characters.

In ancient Mesopotamia, a temple statue of a god was treated as the god’s literal presence. Each city-state had a patron god whose statue lived in the city’s central temple. Mesopotamians believed that the withdrawal of the patron deity’s favor or attention from their city could result in its ruin. In wars between city-states, it was common for the victor to abduct the defeated city’s cult statue.

Imagine a king, a priestess, and a warrior working together to recover their city’s captured cult statue because they believe its return is essential to their city’s survival and recovery.

This could be the plot’s throughline problem (central conflict), or it could be a subplot within a larger story about the ongoing war between the two cities, with the recovery of the cult statue symbolically representing the defeated city’s return to strength.

Such a plot arc feels undeniably authentic because its stakes don’t make sense transplanted to, say, sixteenth-century Florence or twentieth-century China. They’re contingent on beliefs that will feel unfamiliar and interesting to many readers.

An Authentic Character Arc

For character, think about how your setting can generate internal problems.

In the early Byzantine Empire, public entertainers were seen as a low-status class. Their profession was considered degrading and at odds with cultural ideals of dignity and self-command. The stigma could be so powerful that it might shape a person’s entire sense of worth and legitimacy.

Imagine a character whose arc is about overcoming shame associated with being a performer.

Shame is a universal emotion and could become a character arc conflict in any setting. This is fine; most character arcs are about universal emotional experiences. But rooting that shame in Byzantine attitudes toward performers gives the arc a distinctive angle.

The character might wrestle with whether they actually believe their profession is shameful, or whether they’re proud of the discipline and talent it requires. They might question whether the beauty of what they do and the joy it brings to others help balance its social costs.

Or they might gain an unexpected opportunity to move up in society, only to discover that the stigma follows them. Will they keep their head down out of a sense of unworthiness, or will they choose to believe in their own worth even if others don’t?

Note how this example is immediately interesting because it turns a modern assumption on its head. Much of today’s world reveres actors, singers, dancers, and other performers as people of talent, beauty, and influence. This story would require readers to enter a very different cultural mindset, which contributes to immersion.

So…

Can you think of ways to center the setting-specific elements of your story in your plot and character arcs to create a more authentic, immersive experience for readers?

Next
Next

Does your novel need a romance?